IF MedTechStart a project

Idea Validation

Before any engineering money is spent, we test whether the need is real and which of the possible concepts is worth building.

When to use it

When Idea Validation Is the Right Step

At the very start, before any money goes into engineering. You have a clinical problem or an idea for a device, and you need to know if it is worth building.

  • Test a Clinical Need

    You see a problem in your own practice. A workshop tests who has it, how often, and what a good answer looks like.

  • Choose Between Ideas

    You have several ways to solve the problem. Concepts are sketched and compared on the same criteria before one is chosen.

  • Decide Before You Spend

    You need a go, change or stop decision for a board, a grant or yourself, with the evidence written down.

How it works

How Idea Validation Works

  1. Step 1

    Run a Clinical-Need Workshop

    Clinicians, users and engineers describe the problem and where it happens.

  2. Step 2

    Write the Need Down

    The problem, the users and what a good answer looks like, in plain words.

  3. Step 3

    Sketch Concepts

    Industrial designers and engineers draw several ways to solve it.

  4. Step 4

    Check Feasibility

    Each concept is checked against physics, parts, cost drivers and the likely regulatory route.

  5. Step 5

    Select a Concept

    Concepts are compared on the same criteria, and one is chosen for the next stage.

  6. Step 6

    Decide

    Go, change or stop, with the evidence and the reasoning written down.

What you get

What You Bring and What You Get

You Bring

  • The clinical problem, in your own words
  • Who has the problem, and where it happens
  • Any sketches, notes or papers you already have
  • Access to clinicians or users who can join a workshop
  • What a decision needs to show, for you or your funder

You Get Back

  • A written statement of the clinical need and the users
  • A first list of needs that can become design inputs
  • Concept sketches, compared on the same criteria
  • A feasibility view of the chosen concept
  • The main risks and unknowns, listed for the next stage
  • A go, change or stop recommendation, with the reasoning
Questions

Questions Clinicians and Founders Ask

Do I need a patent before I share my idea?

Not to start, but take care. Publishing or showing an invention in public before a patent application is filed can affect whether it can be patented. It is common to sign a non-disclosure agreement first. Prior art and landscape shows what is already out there.

What happens if the answer is stop?

Then you have spent the least on the idea. The reasons are written down, so you can see what would have to change for the answer to become go.

Will I know which regulatory class my device falls in?

You get a first view. In India, the Medical Devices Rules, 2017 place devices in classes A, B, C and D by risk. The class and route tool gives a quick first read.

Have a question about Idea validation?

Opens the contact form with this service named. Nothing is sent until you press send.